![]()
| A Savage Soul (Bronze) | Complete "At Home with Dutch". |
| Austin Overpowered (Silver) | Complete Twin Rocks, Pike's Basin, and Gaptooth Breach Hideouts in Single Player. |
| Bearly Legal (Bronze) | Kill and skin 18 grizzly bears. |
| Buckin' Awesome (Bronze) | Break the Kentucky Saddler, the American Standardbred, and the Hungarian Half-bred. |
| Bullseye (Bronze) | Get 250 headshots in any game mode. |
| Clemency Pays (Bronze) | Capture a bounty alive. |
| Dastardly (Bronze) | Place a hogtied woman on the train tracks, and witness her death by train. |
| Evil Spirits (Silver) | Complete Tumbleweed and Tesoro Azul Hideouts in Single Player. |
| Exquisite Taste (Bronze) | Purchase a rare weapon from a gunsmith. |
| Fightin' Around the World (Bronze) | Knock someone out in melee in every saloon in the game in Single Player. |
| Friends in High Places (Bronze) | Use a pardon letter with more than $5000 bounty in Single Player. |
| Frontiersman (Bronze) | Obtain Legendary rank in any Single Player Ambient Challenge. |
| Go Team! (Silver) | Be on the winning team for four consecutive victories in any team based game in public matches. |
| Gold Medal (Bronze) | Earn a Gold Medal Rank for a combat mission in Single Player. |
| Have Gun Will Travel (Silver) | Complete all Hideouts in a single public Free Roam session. |
| He Cleans Up Well! (Bronze) | Obtain the Elegant Suit. |
| Heading South on a White Bronco (Bronze) | Evade the US Marshals while riding the Hungarian Half-Bred horse in Single Player. |
| High Roller (Bronze) | Win over 2000 chips in a hand of Poker. |
| Hit the Trail (Bronze) | Get from Blackwater to Escalera before sundown in a public Free Roam session. |
| How the West Was Won (Silver) | Reach the top rank for multiplayer experience. |
| In a Hail of Bullets (Silver) | Kill 500 enemies with any pistol or revolver in any game mode. |
| Instinto Asesino (Silver) | Complete Fort Mercer and Nosalida Hideouts in Single Player. |
| Into the Sunset (Gold) | Complete "The Last Enemy That Shall Be Destroyed". |
| Land of Opportunity (Silver) | Complete "The Assault on Fort Mercer". |
| Legend of the West (Platinum) | You've become a true legend of the west! |
| Long Arm of Marston (Silver) | Kill 500 enemies with any rifle, repeater, or shotgun in any game mode. |
| Man of Honor / Chivalry's Dead (Bronze) | Attain highest Fame rank and either highest Honor rank or lowest Honor rank. |
| Manifest Destiny (Bronze) | Kill the last buffalo in the Great Plains in Single Player. |
| More than a Fistful (Bronze) | Earn $10,000 in Single Player. |
| Most Wanted (Bronze) | Become a Public Enemy for 10 minutes and escape alive in a public Free Roam session. |
| Mowing Them Down (Silver) | Kill 500 enemies with a mounted weapon in any game mode. |
| No Dice (Bronze) | Complete a game of Liar's Dice without losing a single die. |
| No More Fancy Words (Silver) | Complete "An Appointed Time". |
| Nurture or Nature? (Gold) | Complete "Remember My Family". |
| On the Trail of de Vaca (Bronze) | Uncover every location on the map in Single Player. |
| People are Still Strange (Silver) | Complete 15 tasks for Strangers. |
| Posse Up! (Bronze) | Create a posse and get the maximum number of members. |
| Red Dead Rockstar (Bronze) | Kill a Rockstar or someone with this Trophy in a public multiplayer match |
| Redeemed (Gold) | Attain 100% in the Single Player Game Completion stat. |
| Slow on the Draw (Bronze) | Get 10 assists in a single Hideout in a public Free Roam session. |
| Sons of Mexico (Silver) | Complete "The Gates of El Presidio". |
| Spurred to Victory (Bronze) | Complete 20 story missions without switching to a new horse at a hitching post. |
| Strange Things are Afoot (Bronze) | Complete a task for Stranger. |
| That Government Boy (Bronze) | Complete "Exodus in America". |
| The Benefits of Civilization (Gold) | Complete "And the Truth Will Set You Free". |
| The Gunslinger (Silver) | Score a headshot on any enemy using Expert targeting mode. |
| The Quick and Everyone Else... (Silver) | Be the top scoring player in any three consecutive FFA games in public matches. |
| Unnatural Selection (Bronze) | Kill one of every animal species in the game in any game mode. |
| What About Hand Grenades? (Bronze) | Get a ringer in a game of Horseshoes. |
